Breast Pump Comparison Chart

Medela Pump In Style Breast Pump
  • Medela Pump In Style Advanced Breast Pump

  • 4.5-star
  • Double Breast Pump
  • System: Open System
  • Adjustable Speed
  • Cycle Control: No
  • Weight: 6 lbs 3 oz
  • Grade: Personal
  • Comfort Flange Material:
    Poly propylene plastic
  • Pros:
    Good value, efficient, portable, easy to use, great accessories
    Reputable manufacturer with decades of experience
    Strong and effective motor
    Two modes (stimulation and expression)
  • Cons:
    A little loud;
    Open collection system which can cause condensation in tubing,
    The accessories aren't as good as the pump. The backpack seems to fall apart after awhile
Spectra Baby S1 Breast Pump
  • Spectra Baby S1 Double/Single Breast Pump

  • 4.5-star
  • Double or Single Breast Pump
  • System: Closed System
  • Adjustable Speed
  • Cycle Control: Yes
  • Weight: 5 lbs 10 oz
  • Grade: Hospital
  • Comfort Flange Material:
    Plastic
  • Pros:
    Efficient, comfortable, portable, super quiet, hygienic, good customer service
    Best pump for safety due to the closed collection system
    Built-in battery and Rechargeable Battery
    One of the quietest Breast Pump on the market Night light & timer, Letdown mode and fully adjustable program to best suit your body
  • Cons:
    Bottles that come with this pump are not great
    No bag included.
    Only one bottle holder and incompatible with pumping bra
Avent Double Breast Pump
  • Philips AVENT Double Electric Comfort Breast Pump

  • 4-star
  • Double Breast Pump
  • System: Closed System
  • Adjustable Speed
  • Cycle Control: No
  • Weight: 2 lbs 12 oz
  • Grade: Personal
  • Comfort Flange Material:
    5-petal silicone cushions
  • Pros:
    Comfortable, Efficent Pump for more milk. Easy to take to work with bag, 3 expression settings (low, medium, high)
    It's a closed system so you don't have to worry about milk backing up in the tubes
  • Cons:
    It's loud.
    If your breasts are on the larger side, you may need to purchase a bigger set of cushions for proper fit.
Avent Double Breast Pump
  • Ameda Purely Yours Ultra Double Electric Breast Pump

  • 3.5-star
  • Double Breast Pump
  • System: Closed System
  • Adjustable Speed
  • Cycle Control: Yes
  • Weight: 4 lbs 12 oz
  • Grade: Personal
  • Comfort Flange Material:
    Poly Propylen plastic
  • Pros:
    Features both stimulation mode and expression mode
    Built-in holder for bottles
    Pumps very fast
    It's a closed system so you don't have to worry about milk backing up in the tubes
  • Cons:
    A few users say that the suction is inconsistent and the need to restart the pump multiple times during a pumping session. Fortunately, Ameda's customer service gets rave reviews for being responsive, so reps will help you troubleshoot any issues that occur.
    Pumps a little slow


Points To Keep In Mind for Breast Pump Comparison

There are different types of breast pumps available in the market fit to suit different needs, keep the below mentioned points in mind to select the best one for you and our breast pump comparison chart

    • Effectiveness

The effectiveness of a pump generally depends on how frequently the pump cycles. Approximately, a nursing baby would suck 45 to 55 times every minute. The closer your pump is to this range, you can be surer of it drawing milk from your breast more effectively. If a pump has cycling rate of less than 25, then it is not likely to prove helpful at expressing milk. Pumps with such low cycling rates, can make the cycles be longer, and thus your breast and nipple might pain since they will be pulled and suctioned for longer duration at a stretch. Auto-cycling pumps are better compared to those pumps that require you to adjust cycling manually The vacuum strength or suction also helps determine how effective it is. The suction strength of most breast pumps that you can get today varies from 0 mm Hg – 250mm Hg. If you opt for a pump that has a vacuum more than 250mm Hg then it can result in lots of pain.

    • Durability

No breast pump is created in the same way. Some come with durable motors that have been created for daily, frequent pumping, while other pumps have smaller motors that are good only if you are interested in occasional pumping. Since there are such variations in durability, it is very important you keep in mind how often you would pump while choosing a breast pump. If a pump is used more often than it has been designed to serve, then its motor might wear out prematurely, and this will only shorten the lifespan of the pump.

    • Type of Pumping

Breast Pump ComparisonThere are three kinds of pumping action – single, double simultaneous, and double alternating. Using single pumps, you can pump just one breast at a time. This type of pump is perfect for occasional pumping. By occasional pumping, it means pumping just once a day. If you work part time or a stay-at-home mother, then this type of pump is ideal for you. Double simultaneous pumps will pump stimulate both your breasts together, and this is amongst the best breast pump you can opt for. If you use a double simultaneous pump you will be able to cut on your overall pumping time, and at the same time increase your milk production. Double Alternating Pump will help stimulate both your breasts, but as the name suggests, at alternating times. So, when there is suction on one breast, milk is released from the other one. Though alternating pumps are better compared to single pumping, they are still not as good as double simultaneous pumps.

    • Comfort Level

Breast pumps come with a breast shield, and they play an important role in determining how comfortable the pump will be. Some pumps have one-size fit breast shield that is to be used by everyone. Mothers who have larger breasts or/and nipples might find this uncomfortable, and this can also come in way of proper milk output. Moreover, the cycling of a pump can also affect its level of comfort. Auto-cycling pumps are more comfortable compared to the manual ones, and they also make the suction procedure faster.

    • Noise Level of the Motor

Even though the noise produced by the pump’s motor might not be a very important factor helping you choose the right breast pump, still this is one of the factors you might want to consider. Some mothers find noisy pumps a distraction whilst they are pumping. Smaller motors are generally nosier compared to the larger ones, so keep this in mind while selecting one for yourself.

    • Power Options

An AC adapter generally is considered the best power source that you can depend upon, but it might not prove to be the wisest option in all conditions. While selecting a pump, you must consider where you will pump. Can there be times where you might not have an electric outlet nearby? Will you be traveling frequently? If yes, then it will be better if you opt for a pump that comes with a car adapter or one that can pump on batteries if needed.

    • Portability

If you will need to pump often, then portability must be one of the most important Breast Pump Comparison factors to consider while choosing the best breast pump, as you will need to carry your pump with you wherever you go. You can determine the portability of a pump depending on its power options, weight, as well as carry bag features.